The Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern

65 S Main St, Johnstown, OH 43031

About The Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern

3.9 / 5 from reviews

Town Coupon Deals

List your business in Licking county’s #1 source for local area merchant reviews, information and deals!

Read More

Featured Business…

Our Address
65 S Main St, Johnstown, OH 43031

Reviews for "The Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern"

Cash Money
January 23, 2019

Just a great place to go. It's old but very clean. Owner did the remodeling. It has interesting historically significant photos all over the rear walls. Lots of wood throughout with tin ceiling tiles. You get the idea. Full menu for dining and bar. You'll get a warm, comfortable feeling in this place.

Jason Burns
November 18, 2018

Kinda weird the server. Was swishing medication she told us....sweet fries way over done... regular fries cold.... had to ask for ketchup and salt.... never got salt... Assume they forgot... And glass had tide mark that was all way around glass and was all greasy that we had to wipe away.... but Beautiful place... great area easy park....blackened chicken looked amazing... and I was told tasted just as good... Will go back to see if just off Friday night.. but arrived at 815 only had 4 customers.... has lot lot of potential.... try it out yourself and decide maybe I just got off night......

Scott Miller
December 17, 2018

We were warned that the kitchen was backed up and food might take an excessive amount of time, but we were pleasantly surprised. Although all we ordered were pizzas. Food was good, waitress was pleasant and attentive. We got a tour of the upstairs banquet area, which was beautiful!

Shawn Stewart
October 19, 2018

Food was good and we had great service from Joseph. The nachos appetizer was huge even for 4 people. Atmosphere was nice and burger was flavorful. Onion rings were crispy. I deducted 1 star for the slightly high prices, but everything else was a good experience.

Tylor New
February 13, 2019

Good service nd great atmosphere, high quality food


Do you have a local business?

Our Jumbo Mailer magically attracts more customers!